Ice Cream / Gelato / Frozen Yogurt / Italian Water Ice/Custard
Absolutely the best homemade ice cream on island! Try new Dolphin Tracks, Sandpiper and Sanibel Sea Shells. Join in our 2020 Captains For Clean Water benefit. Visit the Sanibel Chocolate Shop & Patisserie counter for all-day breakfast, lunch, dinner and snacks, beach-packaged in the shop for on-the-go islanders who love good food. The name may have changed, but we are here to stay on the East End!
362 Periwinkle Way
Sanibel, FL 33957
A Sanibel tradition since 1980, 28+ awards including Best Ice Cream, Best Gelato, & more. This is the real deal! Home of the SANIBEL KRUNCH©, DIRTY SAND DOLLAR©, WEDDING BELLS© and GATOR STEW©, Pinocchio’s is reopening soon to a new location & will serve their generous portions of unique flavors to their loyal fans once again. Yes, we will keep the animal cracker on top. It’s Simply the Best… I cannot tell a lie!
Serving Sanibel & Captiva Islands